Practice Areas
Healthcare Fraud
Massachusetts Health Care Fraud Attorneys for MassHealth, Medicaid, and Medicare Fraud Defense
Are you facing allegations of healthcare fraud? Have you received a subpoena or a civil investigative demand from the Massachusetts Attorney General or the United States Attorney’s Office? Our criminal defense team has experience in healthcare fraud cases, bringing decades of combined experience defending against complex state and federal investigations and prosecutions. We understand the intricate web of regulations governing nursing homes, pharmaceutical companies, medical transportation, and healthcare billing—and we are here to protect your rights and reputation.
Key Takeaways:
- Our firm handles both federal and state healthcare fraud investigations
- We defend against all types of fraud allegations, including those related to billing and record keeping
- Early intervention by our legal team often leads to better case outcomes
- Our attorneys have extensive trial experience in state and federal court
- We implement proactive strategies to minimize potential penalties and protect what matters most—your career, your practice, and your reputation.

Understanding Healthcare Fraud Laws in Massachusetts
Our defense team stays current with the constantly evolving landscape of healthcare fraud regulations. We have successfully defended healthcare providers against allegations involving:
Key Federal and State Regulations Affecting Healthcare Providers
Healthcare providers in Massachusetts must navigate complex layers of regulations:
| Regulation | Level | Key Focus |
| False Claims Act | Federal | Fraudulent claims to government programs |
| Anti-Kickback Statute | Federal | Improper referrals and inducements |
| Stark Law | Federal | Physician self-referrals |
| Massachusetts False Claims Act | State | State-specific fraud prevention |
Common Types of Healthcare Fraud Cases in Massachusetts
- Billing fraud and coding violations
- Identity theft and patient information misuse
- Kickback allegations
- Pharmaceutical and prescription fraud
- Medical device fraud
- False claims for services
- Stark Law violations
Our firm regularly defends against various types of healthcare fraud allegations.
Potential Penalties for Healthcare Fraud Convictions
Although healthcare fraud cases may be handled criminally or civilly, these cases create exposure for potential state and federal prisons sentences. Additionally, they often carry with them demands for substantial restitution in cases of overpayment for improper billing. The restitution is often used as the base number against a multiplier for substantial fines. Finally, these cases are damaging to professional reputations and may have collateral consequences for professional licenses.
Signs You or Your Business Are Under Investigation for Healthcare Fraud
Healthcare fraud investigations often begin long before any formal charges are filed. Our defense team has extensive experience identifying the early warning signs that federal or state authorities have initiated an investigation into your practice. These investigations can start subtly – perhaps with irregular claim rejections or unusual audit requests – but can quickly escalate into full-scale federal investigations involving multiple agencies. Another signal is the receipt of a subpoena or civil investigative demand for records or testimony. Understanding these warning signs is crucial, as early detection allows our firm to intervene proactively, potentially preventing formal charges and protecting your practice’s reputation. Through years of defending healthcare providers, we have identified several key indicators that often precede formal healthcare fraud investigations:
- Unexpected audits or record requests
- Increased scrutiny of billing practices
- Law enforcement inquiries
- Questions about medication prescriptions
- Concerns over drug dispensing procedures
- Visits from investigators
- Civil investigative demands
- Search warrants or subpoenas
The Importance of Early Legal Representation
There are significant risks in facing healthcare fraud charges without proper legal representation. Law enforcement aggressively pursues these cases, often using complex evidence related to Medicare numbers and billing practices. Our firm strongly advises anyone under investigation to contact our office immediately, rather than attempting to handle the situation alone, or worse yet, rely on a State-run hotline.
How Butters Brazilian Can Help
Our healthcare fraud defense team develops strong defense strategies tailored to each client’s unique situation. We meticulously analyze Medicare reimbursement records and federal criminal defense precedents to build compelling cases. Our approach includes:
- Comprehensive case analysis
- Evidence gathering and preservation
- Expert witness consultation
- Strategic motion practice
- Negotiation with prosecutors, including pre-charge “white paper” presentations
- Trial preparation when necessary
Protecting Your Rights Throughout the Process
The criminal defense lawyers at Butters Brazilian can navigate the complex legal system to protect our clients’ rights in Medicare fraud cases. We handle:
- Indictments related to medical device fraud
- Challenges to prosecution’s case
- Negotiations with federal prosecutors
- Trial preparation and representation
- Appeals when necessary
Steps to Take When Accused
If accused of healthcare fraud, take these immediate steps:
- Contact our firm immediately
- Preserve all relevant documents
- Maintain confidentiality
- Follow our legal guidance
- Document all communication with investigators
- Continue normal operations unless advised otherwise
Document Preservation Guidelines
Crucial documents to preserve include:
- Medical records
- Billing statements
- Correspondence with Medicare/Medicaid/MassHealth
- Internal memos and emails
- Compliance documentation
- Staff training records
Preventing Future Healthcare Fraud Allegations
Our firm helps clients implement compliance programs to prevent future investigations:
- Customized compliance protocols
- Staff training programs
- Regular internal audits
- Documentation improvement systems
- Risk management strategies
- Ongoing legal consultation
Our firm helps clients implement compliance programs to prevent future investigations:
- Customized compliance protocols
- Staff training programs
- Regular internal audits
- Documentation improvement systems
- Risk management strategies
- Ongoing legal consultation
Why Choose Our Firm to Defend your Rights
Our healthcare fraud defense practice offers:
- Extensive experience in federal healthcare fraud cases
- Deep understanding of medical billing and coding
- Strong track record of successful outcomes
- Relationships with key experts and investigators
- 24/7 availability for urgent matters
- Personalized attention to every case
Contact Our Law Office
Don’t wait to get experienced legal representation. Contact our Boston office today at (617) 367-2600 to schedule a confidential consultation. Our team will review your situation and outline potential defense strategies to protect your rights, reputation, and freedom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Knowingly submitting false or misleading claims to insurers or public health programs.
Making false statements about whether services were “medically necessary.”
Engaging in kickback or referral schemes that violate state or federal anti-kickback laws.
The False Health Care Claims Act (M.G.L. Chapter 175H) covers false claims and misrepresentations in health care coverage or benefit claims.
The Massachusetts Medicaid False Claims laws.
Federal laws including the False Claims Act, anti-kickback statutes, and laws against false statements to government health care programs.
Civil penalties: repayment of false or overbilled amounts, possibly multiplied, plus attorney’s fees and investigation costs.
Criminal penalties: fines and imprisonment depending on severity and whether federal or state charges.
Additional sanctions could include exclusion from government health programs, loss of professional license, reputational harm.
State investigations are conducted by the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Medicaid Fraud Division and other state regulatory or licensing boards.
Federal investigations may involve the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Office of Inspector General, DOJ, Medicare/Medicaid auditors, etc.
Investigations often include audits of billing records, examination of medical necessity, reviews of provider referrals, kickbacks or inducements, document subpoenas.
Retain experienced legal counsel right away.
Preserve all relevant records and documentation (claims data, medical charts, communications).
Evaluate whether there were any policies, procedures, or compliance programs in place, and whether cooperation or self-reporting might help reduce exposure.
Understand the possible defenses (e.g. lack of intent, error vs knowing fraud, whether services were legitimate or necessary).
Are You Ready For A Consultation?
Related Attorneys

Meredith Fierro
Counsel

Patrick Hanley
Partner

Elizabeth K. Keeley
Partner

Mary E. Lemay
Counsel

Alec S. Pine
Partner

Matthew D. Thompson
Partner

Karen M. Wells
Special Counsel