Attorneys Butters, Pine, and Thompson

We are proud to announce that Butters Brazilian LLP partners Alec S. Pine, Thomas Butters, and Matthew Thompson secured a $1.9 million settlement for a pedestrian catastrophically injured by a pick-up truck in Boston’s West End neighborhood. This resolution represents a 1,480% increase over the initial settlement offer, reflecting our firm’s dedication to advocating for injury victims.

In July 2021, our 29-year-old client was walking along Charles Street in Boston’s West End on a clear summer day. After arriving at an intersection, she began crossing the street just outside, but adjacent to, a crosswalk. At that moment, a driver operating a large pick-up truck made a right-hand turn, striking her and knocking her to the ground. The truck initially stopped with its front right tire pinning one of her legs to the ground. In a panicked attempt to move it off her, the driver reversed—but instead of freeing her, he stopped the truck on top of her other leg, pinning her for a second time. Only after a second attempt did he manage to fully move the truck off her, but by then, the damage was devastating.

Her injuries were life-altering. She suffered a traumatic brain injury (TBI), multiple fractures to her jaw and face, broken ribs and a broken kneecap. The impact also caused the loss of several teeth, requiring extensive reconstructive surgery and dental treatment. She endured severe nerve damage, road rash to her legs, and cognitive difficulties, including memory loss. The physical and emotional toll was immense, affecting nearly every aspect of her daily life, and forcing her withdrawal from graduate school.

Despite the severe nature of her injuries, the defendants aggressively contested liability and damages. They argued that our client crossed outside the designated crosswalk, that she was distracted by her cell phone, and claimed that the driver’s visibility was obstructed by a blind spot. They also challenged the existence and severity of her traumatic brain injury. Furthermore, they disputed vicarious liability, contending that the driver was using his personal vehicle and was not acting within the scope of his employment at the time of the collision.

To counter these defenses and establish liability, our firm conducted a comprehensive investigation. We obtained an exemplar vehicle of the same make and model as the defendant’s truck and performed a full visibility analysis at the accident scene with our accident reconstruction expert. This critical analysis proved that the driver should have seen our client before impact, directly refuting claims that she was entirely outside his field of view.

Additionally, we worked with top experts to substantiate the TBI diagnosis and its impact. We engaged an economist, vocational rehabilitation expert, and life care planner to project the long-term financial and medical costs of her injuries.

Just two weeks before trial, after extensive litigation, the case settled for $1.9 million—an outcome that will ensure our client receives the care and support she needs for the rest of her life.

This case is a stark reminder of the dangers of driver inattention, particularly in urban areas with heavy pedestrian traffic. Our client’s courage and perseverance throughout both her recovery and the legal process led to the result she deserved.

Attorney Alec S. Pine leads our personal injury practice, where we take on high-stakes cases with determination and individualized care. If you or a loved one has been seriously injured, contact us at (617) 367-2600 to learn how we can help.